Court Records

In November 2025, The New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division affirmed that the Monroe Township Board of Education violated the Open Public Meetings Act (OPMA) when it filled a board vacancy. It also affirmed—as modified—a Law Division order voiding the board’s appointment vote.

The published opinion in Michele Arminio v. Monroe Township Board of Education (Docket No. A-0207-24) addresses what a public body can discuss in a closed executive session during an appointment process—and what must be disclosed and discussed after returning to the public meeting before a vote. The published opinion is here: Arminio v. Monroe Twp. Bd. of Educ. (A-0207-24).

The U.S. Department of Justice filed a federal lawsuit on February 26, 2026, seeking a court order that would require New Jersey to produce records from its Statewide Voter Registration List (the “SVRL”), including “all fields” the department says it demanded in earlier letters.

The case, United States v. Caldwell, was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey (D.N.J.) as a statutory records-demand enforcement action under the Civil Rights Act record-demand provisions, according to the complaint. The defendant is Dale G. Caldwell, sued in his official capacity as New Jersey’s lieutenant governor and secretary of state, court documents indicate.

The complaint says DOJ is seeking the SVRL records to assess New Jersey’s compliance with federal voter-registration list maintenance requirements, including those in the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA) and the Help America Vote Act (HAVA).

Federal courts in California, Michigan, and Oregon have recently dismissed lawsuits by the Department of Justice that sought to force states to hand over full, unredacted voter registration lists, including sensitive personal data. Those rulings signal growing judicial resistance to the DOJ’s broader campaign to obtain private voter information from dozens of states, with judges warning the efforts could threaten voter privacy and state control of elections.

A civil lawsuit alleging retaliation, political interference, and misuse of public records within the Middletown school system has entered a new procedural phase. With a consolidated Answer now filed on behalf of the district and all school-affiliated defendants, the case moves from motions practice toward structured discovery.

The matter remains relevant beyond the named parties. It concerns the employment of a tenured educator turned town Toms River Mayor, the conduct of elected Board of Education officials, and the use of public institutions during an active political period.

A new civil lawsuit filed in Superior Court in Monmouth County raises questions about how the Monmouth County Sheriff’s Office moderates comments on its official Facebook page and whether those practices violate state constitutional free-speech protections.

The case¹, brought by Laurie Tietjen against the Monmouth County Sheriff’s Office and Sheriff Shaun Golden, alleges that her comments on the Sheriff’s Office Facebook page were selectively restricted or hidden from public view through a practice commonly described as “shadowbanning,” while remaining visible to her when she was logged into her account.